Unexpected developments in case law

Vacation law and overtime hours

In the past ten years, no stone was left standing in German vacation law; this was ensured collaboratively by CJEU and BAG (the German Federal Labor Court). Certainties, having been true for decades, have been reversed. Starting with the new regulations regarding the lapse of vacation in the event of sickness, to the abandonment of the “surrogate” theory, which inevitably needed to be followed by the inheritance of vacation entitlements, through to the last coup: the employer’s duty to give notice. Precisely this ruling will lead to an enormous administrative burden on the part of the employer. Because the BAG asserted that the employer has the duty to inform every employee in writing on his vacation entitlements and the possible lapse of the same. And he has to do so year after year again.

But there is also a silver lining, for example, the clarification that during the exemption phase of partial retirement no vacation days can be accumulated. However, the overall legal position of the employers deteriorates more and more.

In general, it can be observed that more and more courts consider the employer as such to be uncapable to take care of his own affairs. Recently, a colleague of mine spoke of “helicopter courts”. Frankly speaking, we a really not very far from it anymore.

x

Related articles:

Issue 02/2014 Current labor law

Changing case law pertaining to leave entitlements –

One can rightfully state that the law pertaining to leave entitlements has been subject to radical change in the last couple of years – and relatively rarely in favor of employers. This paper...

more
Issue 02/2013 Current labor law

Provisos on the discretionary nature of payments and their revocation in employment contracts – How long will they continue to exist?

Can entitlements to benefits be effectively excluded in the future? The use of provisos governing the discretionary nature of payments and their revocation in employment contracts aims to exclude a...

more
Issue 02/2014 Setting prices in a keen competition

Using creative leeway with legal certainty –

Breaches of the competition laws may have serious consequences. First and foremost, there is the monetary fine imposed on companies. This can amount to maximum 10?% of the entire sales volume...

more
Issue 02/2017 New regulations for temporary work and the contract for work

Good things come to those who wait?

The topic “deployment of external staff” does not come to peace. After the confusion caused by the German Minimum Wage Law introduced in 2015, employers will have to struggle with changes to legal...

more